By Mark Harris Friday, 17 March 2023
This technical review will provide a comprehensive, thoughtful, and systematic analysis of the performance of Murata Electronics' GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor compared to a statistical benchmark formed from other components of the same value. The capacitor is a ceramic X6T type with a nominal value of 100n, a tolerance of ±20%, a voltage rating of 4, and is designed for surface mount applications in a 01005 (0402 Metric) package.
The following sections of this review will delve into the analysis and comparison of the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor concerning capacitance, series resistance, dissipation factor, and quality factor, exploring the reasons behind its performance characteristics in relation to the benchmark data. This analysis aims to provide engineers with in-depth insights into the suitability of this component for inclusion in their electronic products.
In this section, we will analyze the impedance performance of the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor. When comparing the component's impedance measurements at 1V and 4V against provided benchmark data, we can observe that its performance lies within the range of the benchmark data. At a significant number of test frequencies, the capacitor has an impedance that is lower than the average impedance of the statistical benchmark, indicating that it is performing well in this aspect.
For example, at a test frequency of 5kHz, the capacitor has an impedance of 336.3 Ohms at 1V, which is slightly above the average benchmark impedance of 325.6 Ohms but still within the minimum and maximum range (294 to 356.1 Ohms). At higher voltages, such as 4V, the capacitor maintains its performance and continues to fall within the benchmark range.
However, it is essential to note that the capacitor's impedance tends to increase when the voltage is raised from 1V to 4V. For example, at 5kHz, the capacitor's impedance increases from 336.3 Ohms at 1V to 447.9 Ohms at 4V. At higher test frequencies, this trend persists, indicating that the capacitor may experience higher impedance levels in applications with higher voltage ratings. This behavior is a typical characteristic of capacitors, as the capacitance decreases with increasing voltage, leading to a higher impedance, especially in the case where higher voltage stress is experienced.
Overall, the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor exhibits satisfactory performance in terms of impedance, with measurements that lie within the benchmark ranges at both 1V and 4V test conditions. While the capacitor experiences an increase in impedance with higher voltages, it maintains acceptable performance levels and can be considered a suitable candidate for engineers evaluating capacitors for their circuits. It is crucial for an engineer to remember that impedance behavior with voltage increases may impact the overall circuit performance, depending on its specific requirements and operating conditions.
In reviewing the GRM022D80G104ME15L ceramic X6T capacitor from Murata Electronics, the LCR measurements taken at 1V across different test frequencies reveal capacitance values ranging from 73.21nF to 98.37nF. It is important to note that capacitor values can vary within a tolerance range specified by the manufacturer. These measurements demonstrate a moderate capacitance performance when compared to the benchmark data, which shows an average series capacitance ranging from 82.53nF to 101.8nF.
Upon further examination, it is notable that the measured capacitance values for the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor generally fall within the range denoted by the minimum series capacitance (90.07nF to 62nF) and maximum series capacitance (110.3nF to 115nF) from the benchmark data. In the context of practical applications, capacitance values close to their nominal value are desirable for optimal circuit performance. Nevertheless, certain test frequencies indicate suboptimal performance: for instance, at the 50kHz, 100kHz, and 200kHz frequency marks, the capacitor's capacitance lies closer to the lower-end of the benchmark range, potentially affecting its suitability for applications that require specific frequency-dependent performance.
When analyzing the capacitor's performance at an increased voltage of 4V, the LCR measurements reveal a distinctive shift in capacitance: the values range from 70.99nF to 89.33nF, signifying a broader deviation from the benchmark averages. This indicates a decline in capacitance performance as the voltage increases, which is common among ceramic capacitors experiencing voltage coefficient of capacitance (VCC) effects. Such effects can significantly impact the overall performance of the component within a circuit, particularly in applications where stable capacitance over a range of voltage levels is critical.
In this section, we will analyze the series resistance of Murata Electronics' GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor and compare its performance to the average values of a statistical benchmark for other components with the same capacitance value. Series resistance is an important parameter as it can influence the equivalent series inductance (ESL) and equivalent series resistance (ESR) of a capacitor. These factors are crucial for determining the performance of a capacitor, particularly in high-frequency applications where minimal losses and signal distortion are desired.
When tested at 1 Volt, the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor exhibits a lower series resistance compared to the average values of the benchmark across a majority of the test frequencies. Specifically, at 50 kHz, the capacitor's series resistance (1.64 Ohms) is significantly lower than the benchmark's average (1.039 Ohms). This trend is consistently observed for test frequencies ranging from 100 kHz to 1 MHz, indicating that the capacitor demonstrates superior performance in high-frequency applications, minimizing resistive losses.
When increasing the voltage to 4 Volts, the capacitor's series resistance performance is not significantly impacted. Although there are slight increases in the series resistance values across most test frequencies, the GRM022D80G104ME15L still maintains its edge over the average benchmark data. For example, at 50 kHz and 4 Volts, the capacitor's series resistance of 1.436 Ohms remains lower than the benchmark's average of 1.039 Ohms. Hence, this capacitor manages to perform well with an acceptable series resistance even at elevated voltage levels, which is essential for reliable operation in various electronic circuits and systems.
This section evaluates the performance of Murata Electronics' GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor based on its Dissipation Factor (Df) and Quality Factor (Q). Understanding the Df and Q parameters is vital as they represent the component's energy loss and efficiency, respectively, under varying conditions.
In the comparison of LCR measurements of the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor at different voltages, specifically at 1 Volt and 4 Volts, the Df values illustrate that the component has a lower energy loss at 4 Volts across the majority of test frequencies. For example, at a test frequency of 100 kHz, the Df value is 0.039 at 1 Volt while it drops to 0.029 at 4 Volts, indicating better performance in higher voltage conditions.
As for the Quality Factor, higher Q values are generally more desirable because they indicate the efficiency of the component with respect to energy storage and loss. The GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor displays better Q values at 4 Volts compared to 1 Volt in various test frequencies. Taking a test frequency of 50 kHz as an example, the Q values are 35.44 at 4 Volts and 25.38 at 1 Volt, indicating increased efficiency at higher voltages.
When comparing the derived results with the available statistical benchmark data, it can be concluded that the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor performs either on par or slightly above the benchmark concerning its Df and Q values. Therefore, electronics engineers who are evaluating this capacitor for integration into their projects can consider it a suitable option for applications that demand low Df (lower energy losses) and high Q factor (greater energy storage efficiency).
In this comparative analysis, we will examine the performance of Murata Electronics' GRM022D80G104ME15L Ceramic: X6T capacitor, comparing its LCR measurements to the statistical benchmark data of other capacitors with the same value. Focusing on aspects such as impedance, dissipation factor, quality factor, series resistance, and series capacitance across varying frequencies, this analysis aims to provide a comprehensive and in-depth understanding of the component's efficacy in comparison to the provided benchmark.
Assessing the impedance behavior, the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor demonstrates higher impedance values compared to the benchmark average impedance in most test frequencies. While this contrast persists across both 1 Volt and 4 Volt measurements, such deviation could affect the component's ability to effectively process signals. For example, at 50 kHz and 1 Volt, this capacitor's impedance registers at 32.8 kOhms, as opposed to the average benchmark value of 31.67 kOhms. This tendency to exhibit higher impedance warrants further consideration when evaluating its potential impact on circuit performance.
When observing the GRM022D80G104ME15L's dissipation factor, it aligns fairly closely with the benchmark average dissipation factor across the majority of test frequencies. It's worth noting that, in particular, the 1 Volt measurement at 400 kHz registers a dissipation factor of 0.036 compared to the average benchmark of 0.040. This similarity is also echoed in the quality factor values, as the GRM022D80G104ME15L typically demonstrates a slightly lower quality factor than the benchmark data.
Examining the series resistance, this capacitor records higher series resistance than the benchmark average across most frequencies, which might impact the power efficiency within a circuit. However, it's essential to consider the difference in series capacitance as well, where the capacitor occasionally exhibits a smaller value than the benchmark average. An example of this is evident at the 500 kHz and 1 Volt, where the capacitor measures a series capacitance of 74.89 nF in contrast to the benchmark's average of 83.64 nF.
In conclusion, the Murata Electronics' GRM022D80G104ME15L Capacitor exhibits some deviation from the benchmark average data, particularly in terms of impedance and series resistance. It is crucial for engineers evaluating this capacitor for utilization in their circuits to consider the potential implications of these differences on overall circuit performance and decide whether these deviations align with their specific design requirements.
Upon a comprehensive and systematic analysis of the Murata Electronics GRM022D80G104ME15L Ceramic X6T capacitor's performance, it is evident that its LCR measurements display a mixed outcome when compared to the statistical benchmark data. Based on the provided information, this capacitor exhibits a varying Dissipation Factor and Quality Factor throughout the different test frequencies. At certain points, it outperforms the benchmark, while it falls slightly behind at other frequencies.
Specifically, this capacitor shows better performance than benchmarks at higher test frequencies and voltage ratings, with higher Quality Factors around 50kHz and even lower Dissipation Factors. However, at lower frequencies and lower voltage rating, the capacitor falls below the benchmark average values in Quality Factors and dissipates more energy as it further deviates from the statistical benchmark. Considering the data comparison on Series Resistance, the capacitor showcases a slightly higher value in the low-frequency range but performs consistently with benchmarks in the higher frequencies area.
In summary, the GRM022D80G104ME15L capacitor demonstrates suitable performance levels in certain frequency ranges but should improve performance in lower frequency ranges. Degreed engineers should consider this analysis as they decide whether the capacitor meets their specific application requirements. Further evaluation on additional technical aspects and real-world tests may provide invaluable information before making the final decision regarding the adoption of this capacitor in their products.